Blog

Blog

Lower Energy Prices May Not Benefit European Shareholders

share

fb-icon tweet-icon
Apme Fx | Lower Energy Prices May Not Benefit European Shareholders

A decline in energy prices would ease pressure on the European economy, but it could also weaken a sector that makes a substantial contribution to corporate earnings growth. Buyers, meanwhile, may not benefit from the savings immediately. For stock selection, it therefore matters when companies' existing supply contracts expire and on what terms they are replaced. Companies whose expensive contracts are nearing expiry could see profitability improve even without higher sales. Businesses previously protected by low-cost hedges, however, could end up paying more even as market prices fall.[1]

Energy Accounts for Much of Earnings Growth

According to a report published by financial data provider LSEG on October 29, 2026, aggregate third-quarter earnings for a sample of 305 companies in the STOXX Europe 600 index are expected to rise by 23.6% year on year. Excluding the energy sector, growth would be 9.8%. The figures combine reported results with estimates for companies that have yet to announce their earnings. Of the total expected increase of €31.1 billion, €19.5 billion is attributable to the energy sector, representing approximately 63% based on our calculation. Other sectors are also recording aggregate earnings growth, but energy is making a substantial contribution to the overall result.

High energy prices, meanwhile, remain a burden on the EU economy. According to Eurostat, the EU covered approximately 57% of its energy needs through net imports in 2024. Lower prices would reduce costs for households and businesses, including those that are not publicly listed. This benefit, however, cannot be directly equated with earnings trends among companies included in an equity index. The STOXX Europe 600 also includes companies from the United Kingdom and Switzerland, meaning it does not provide an exact representation of the EU economy. Lower energy prices could therefore coincide with improving economic conditions across Europe while weaker results from energy companies hold back overall corporate earnings growth.[2]

Some of the Savings May Remain With Refiners

The benefits of cheaper energy are not distributed evenly among businesses. TotalEnergies' results for the third quarter of 2026 illustrate this. The average price of Brent crude fell from $103.8 to $97 per barrel* compared with the second quarter, yet the company's adjusted net profit increased from $6.0 billion to $9.1 billion. Higher natural gas prices, commodity trading results and stronger refining margins supported earnings.

Refiners benefit when crude oil becomes cheaper while prices for refined fuels remain elevated. The European refining margin indicator used by TotalEnergies increased from $13.5 to $33.2 per barrel. It reflects the relationship between the value of refined fuels, crude oil prices and processing costs. A decline in Brent prices therefore does not, on its own, indicate how much a transport operator will save on diesel or an airline on jet fuel. Part of the benefit may remain with the refiner. When assessing future financial results, it is therefore important to monitor the price of the specific input a company purchases and the terms of its supply arrangements.

Existing Contracts Also Determine Energy Costs

A lower market price for fuel does not necessarily translate immediately into lower costs for the buyer. Ryanair, for example, hedges part of its fuel requirements in advance through financial contracts designed to protect it against price increases. According to results released on November 2, the airline had hedged 80% of its expected jet fuel consumption for the financial year ending in March 2027 at approximately $67 per barrel. For the following financial year, it had hedged 25% of consumption at approximately $95 per barrel.

The newer hedges are therefore approximately 42% more expensive, based on our calculation, although they cover only a quarter of future consumption. This does not represent a forecast increase in the company's total fuel bill, but rather a comparison of prices across two sets of contracts. The example illustrates why a company may pay more after its lower-priced contracts expire even when market prices are falling: current market prices may still exceed those agreed previously. Conversely, a company whose expensive contracts are nearing expiry may achieve savings by renewing them at lower prices. Investors should therefore compare the terms of new supply contracts with the costs a company is actually reporting today.

Lower Costs Can Lift Profits Even as Revenue Falls

Lower input costs can create opportunities for stronger earnings even without sales growth. In manufacturing, declining raw material prices often coincide with lower selling prices for finished goods. The result may be lower revenue, but that does not necessarily indicate a weaker business.

BASF's results illustrate the relationship between prices and sales. In the third quarter of 2026, the company increased revenue by 14% year on year, with selling prices rising by 12% and sales volumes by 2%. Higher raw material prices also contributed to inventories tying up an additional €507 million in cash during the quarter.

Under the opposite conditions, the company could report lower revenue while earning more per unit sold, provided its costs declined faster than its selling prices. Replenishing the same quantity of inventory would also require less cash. Such an improvement depends on demand remaining sufficiently strong and competition not forcing the company to pass on all the savings to customers.

It therefore makes sense to look for investment opportunities among companies whose expensive contracts are approaching expiry, that can maintain sales volumes and convert part of the cost savings into higher profitability. Share prices, however, may respond to this change before stronger financial results are reported. Stock selection therefore depends on the scale of the cost reductions ahead and how much of the expected benefit is already reflected in market prices.[3]

* Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

[1]-[3] Forward-looking statements are based on assumptions and current expectations, which may be inaccurate, or based on the current economic environment which is subject to change. Such statements are not guaranteeing of future performance. They involve risks and other uncertainties which are difficult to predict. Results could differ materially from those expressed or implied in any forward-looking statements.

Sources:

https://lipperalpha.refinitiv.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/TRPR_83201_670.pdf

https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/en/web/interactive-publications/energy-2026

https://stoxx.com/index/sxxr/

https://www.nasdaq.com/press-release/totalenergies-se-third-quarter-2026-results-2026-10-29

https://investor.ryanair.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/H1-FY27-Ryanair-Results.pdf

https://www.basf.com/cn/en/media/news-releases/asia-pacific/2026/10/apac-26-120

Disclaimer:

The material herein is considered as marketing communication under the relevant laws and regulations, and as such is not a subject to any prohibition on dealing ahead of the dissemination of investment research. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and should not be construed as containing investment advice, or an investment recommendation, or an offer of or solicitation for any transactions in financial instruments. The published content is intended for educational/informational purposes only. It does not take into account readers’ financial situation, personal experience or investment objectives. APME FX Trading Europe Ltd makes no representation that the information provided is accurate, current or complete; and therefore, assumes no liability for any losses arising from investments based on the supplied content. The past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

Blog

New Zealand Dollar Plummets: Central Bank Surprises the Market by Not Raising Rates

On October 28, 2026, the New Zealand dollar weakened by more than 1% after the country’s central bank left its benchmark interest rate at 2.75%.* The decision surprised...

Blog

British inflation is accelerating, and debt has surpassed 3 trillion GBP

The British economy is facing faster price growth as the government prepares for the fall budget. Data released on October 21, 2026, showed that September inflation reac...

Blog

Electric Mobility in the Czech Republic: No Revolution in Sight; Not Even the Oil Crisis Brought About a Sharp Turn

The rise in oil prices following the escalation of the conflict in the Middle East has increased the economic appeal of battery-electric vehicles, as they generally have...

🍪 Cookies

We use cookies to store, access and process personal data to give you the best online experience. By clicking Accept Cookies you consent to storing all cookies and ensure best website performance. You can modify cookie preferences or withdraw consent by clicking Cookie Settings. To find out more about cookies and purposes, read our Cookie Policy and Privacy Notice.

Cookies settings


Cookie Control

What are cookies?

Cookies are small text files that enable us, and our service provides to uniquely identify your browser or device. Cookies normally work by assigning a unique number to your device and are stored on your browser by the websites that you visit as well as third-party service providers for those website. By the term cookies other technologies as SDKs, pixels and local storage are to be considered.


If Enabled

We may recognize you as a customer which enables customized services, content and advertising, services effectiveness and device recognition for enhanced security
We may improve your experience based on your previous session
We can keep track of your preferences and personalize services
We can improve the performance of Website.


If Disabled

We won't be able to remember your previous sessions, that won't allow us to tailor the website according to your preferences
Some features might not be available and user experience reduced without cookies


Strictly necessary means that essential functions of the Website can not be provided without using them. Because these cookies are essential for the properly working and secure of Website features and services, you cannot opt-out of using these technologies. You can still block them within your browser, but it might cause the disfunction of basic website features.

  • Setting privacy preferences
  • Secure log in
  • Secure connection during the usage of services
  • Filling forms

Analytics and performance tracking technologies to analyze how you use the Website.

  • Most viewed pages
  • Interaction with content
  • Error analysis
  • Testing and Measuring various design effectivity

The Website may use third-party advertising and marketing technologies.

  • Promote our services on other platforms and websites
  • Measure the effectiveness of our campaigns

CFDs are complex instruments and carry a high risk of losing money quickly due to leverage, 71.07% of retail investors' accounts are lost when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing money. Please read the Risk Warning.